He told me he went to the store alone. The bags told a different story. Here is how one tiny detail exposed a year-long affair.
My husband, Dave, is a man of chaos. He is the type of guy who throws his clothes on the floor, leaves cabinet doors open, and—crucially—tosses groceries into the backseat of the car so haphazardly that I usually have to chase apples around the floor mats when he gets home.
So, when he volunteered to go to the grocery store on a Tuesday night to get milk and eggs, I didn’t think much of it. “I’ll be quick,” he said.
He was gone for three hours. When he finally walked through the door, he looked flustered. “Sorry,” he huffed. “Traffic was a nightmare. And the checkout lines were insane. I had to do self-checkout.”
The Clue
He set three plastic grocery bags on the kitchen island. I looked at him. Then I looked at the bags. My stomach dropped.
Every single bag was tied. And they weren’t just tied; they were tied in a perfect, tight double-loop knot. It was the kind of knot you make to ensure nothing spills during a long car ride. It was the kind of knot a mother makes. Or a woman who likes things tidy.
The Logic:
-
Dave is lazy. In 10 years of marriage, he has never once tied a grocery bag. He considers it a waste of time.
-
Dave used self-checkout. Cashiers sometimes tie bags. Self-checkout machines do not.
-
Dave was driving. You can’t tie bags into double knots while driving.
This meant someone else was in the car. Someone sat in the passenger seat, holding those bags, and tied them to keep them safe while he drove. And since Dave claimed he was “alone in traffic,” that person was a secret.
The Trap
I didn’t yell. I decided to test the theory. “Did you run into anyone at the store?” I asked casually, starting to unpack the eggs. “No, just in and out,” he said, grabbing a beer. “Why?”
“Oh, nothing,” I said. “It’s just that these bags are tied. You never tie bags.” He froze. His beer stopped halfway to his mouth. “Oh… uh, yeah,” he stammered. “The… the bag boy did it.”
“You said you used self-checkout.”
The silence that followed was louder than any scream.
The Car Check
“Give me your keys,” I said. “Why?” “I want to check the car.”
I walked out to the driveway. I opened the passenger door. Two things confirmed my suspicion:
-
The seat was moved forward. Dave is 6’2″. I am 5’8″. We keep the seat back. Whoever sat there was short.
-
I put my hand on the leather seat. It was warm.
I walked back inside and threw the keys on the table. “Who is she, Dave? And don’t lie. The seat is still warm, and unless the ‘bag boy’ rode home with you, you’re busted.”
The Confession
He crumbled. It was his coworker, Sarah. She needed a ride home, he claimed. Then he admitted they stopped for “a drink.” Then he admitted it had been going on for six months. Sarah is a notorious neat freak. Of course she tied the bags. She probably couldn’t stand watching them flop around in the backseat.
Her need for order was his downfall.
The Aftermath
We are currently separated. Dave is living in an apartment where I assume he has to tie his own trash bags now. He still tells people I’m “crazy” and “paranoid,” but I tell them I’m just observant. Ladies, trust your gut. If the pattern changes—even something as small as a knot in a plastic bag—pay attention. The details never lie.
